Approval is where co-op programs go to die. A dealer builds an ad, emails it to a regional manager, waits, revises, waits again, and by the time approval arrives the promotion window has closed. The fix is not to remove accountability. It is to approve the right things, once, and let everything else move.
Start by separating three different approvals
Most programs use one word for three different decisions.
- Creative approval. Is this ad on brand and within the program's content rules? In the plans we track, 81% require this for every ad, and the content rules are remarkably consistent: current logo, product illustrated, brand name prominent, no competing products, no claims the manufacturer does not make, no distress pricing.
- Eligibility approval. Is this location allowed to spend, does it have the balance, is the media type eligible, is it inside the claim window? Seventy-seven percent of plans tie eligibility to dealer status or account standing.
- Spend approval. Does someone with budget authority agree this purchase should happen at this size?
The first two are rule checks. A human reviewing them adds delay without adding judgment. The third is a real decision, and it is the only one that should route to a person.
Move creative approval upstream
Approve the template once, not the ad every time. If the logo zone is locked, the product image comes from the approved library, and the copy zones accept only pre-cleared phrases, the ad cannot violate the content rules. Sixty-two of the plans in our data already recognize this with a "pre-approved ads, send approval notice" path. Make that the only path and the creative queue empties.
Automate eligibility entirely
Balance, media type, claim window, tier, and account status are all facts the system knows. Check them at the moment of purchase and block anything that fails. There is nothing for a reviewer to weigh.
Design the spend chain around thresholds, not titles
The mistake is routing everything to the same people. A $400 direct mail drop and a $40,000 regional TV buy do not need the same signatures.
- Below a self-serve threshold, the location spends against its own balance with no approval. Set the threshold where a mistake is affordable.
- Above it, one approver: the regional or district manager who actually owns the relationship. One person, one decision, a service-level target of two business days.
- Above a second threshold, or for anything drawing corporate funds rather than the location's own accrual, add corporate sign-off.
Three levels is the ceiling. Every additional signature roughly doubles the wait and halves the chance anyone reads it.
Make the same event do double duty
The single biggest source of reconciliation work is approving a claim in one place and making the purchase in another. When the approval and the purchase are the same event, the approved amount is the spent amount by definition, and the claim is complete the moment the ad runs. That eliminates the 60-day claim deadline that 85% of legacy plans impose, because there is nothing left to submit.
Measure the chain
Track two numbers: median hours from request to decision, and the share of requests that come back for revision. If the first is above 48 hours the chain has too many steps. If the second is above 10%, the rules are not encoded clearly enough upstream and reviewers are doing work the templates should do.
Co-Op Command handles the fund, the spend, and the reporting in one system.
Request a Demo →